Learn when and why workers’ comp might
offer a settlement and how to determine
if accepting it is in your best interest
If you’ve ever suffered a serious workplace injury, you’re probably already aware that the workers’ compensation process can seem overly complicated, especially when it comes to determining if you should accept a settlement from workers’ comp.
Understanding when and why these offers are made and how to determine if they’re in your best interest can help you make an informed decision about your medical care and financial future. This guide will discuss some common reasons behind settlement offers, the types of cases most likely to receive a settlement, the critical points in the claims process when settlements are usually offered, and key questions to ask yourself before accepting one.
If you live in North Carolina and want help negotiating a workers’ comp settlement or determining if a settlement offer is sufficient to cover your future medical and financial needs, contact the experienced Charlotte workers’ compensation attorneys at Wilder Pantazis Law Group to schedule a free consultation.
Why might workers’ comp offer a settlement?
Workers’ compensation insurance companies might offer a settlement for a variety of reasons, but the decision is primarily driven by financial considerations and risk management:
- Financial predictability. Settlements can be a way for insurance companies to limit their financial exposure. By offering a lump-sum payment, they can avoid the potential for ongoing medical expenses, lost wage benefits, and the possibility of a larger award if the case goes to court.
- Streamlining case management. Settling a claim allows the insurance company to close the case and move on, freeing them from the ongoing administrative and legal costs associated with managing an open claim.
- Dispute resolution. Settlements can be an effective way to resolve disputes between the injured worker and the insurance company, particularly if there are disagreements about the extent of the injury, the need for future medical care, or the worker’s ability to return to work.
Essentially, a settlement allows the insurance company to minimize its risk and payout while potentially offering the injured worker a quicker resolution and avoiding the uncertainties of a trial.
What types of workers’ comp cases are most likely to end in a settlement?
While any workers’ comp claim could potentially end in a settlement, in our experience, the following situations are most likely to result in a settlement offer from workers’ comp:
- Cases with permanent impairment. When an injury results in a permanent disability that affects the worker’s ability to earn a living, settlements are often pursued to compensate for the long-term impact on the worker’s life and career.
- Complex medical conditions. Cases involving complicated medical issues or the need for extensive ongoing treatment, like spinal cord or brain injuries, often lead to settlements. This is because it can be difficult to predict the future costs of medical care, making a lump-sum settlement an attractive option for both parties.
- High-value claims. When the potential value of a claim is high due to severe injuries, lost wages, or ongoing medical needs, settlements are more likely. Insurance companies may be willing to offer a substantial settlement to avoid the risk of a larger payout at trial.
Additionally, injured workers who are represented by experienced attorneys are more likely to receive settlement offers because attorneys can effectively negotiate with insurance companies and ensure that their clients receive fair compensation for their injuries.
When does workers’ comp usually offer a settlement?
Workers’ compensation insurance companies typically consider offering a settlement at 2 key points in the claims process: after reaching maximum medical improvement (MMI) and before trial during mediation.
After reaching maximum medical improvement
Reaching maximum medical improvement (MMI) can be a pivotal moment in the workers’ compensation process. This term refers to a point where your doctor has determined that your condition has stabilized and further medical treatment, while it may offer some relief, is unlikely to significantly improve your overall health or functionality.
For example, if you suffered a severe knee injury at work, MMI might be reached when your doctor determines that your knee pain has plateaued and further physical therapy or other treatments are unlikely to provide substantial improvement. This doesn’t necessarily mean you’re fully healed or pain-free, but rather that your condition has reached a point of stability.
Why is MMI significant for settlements?
Because once you reach MMI, the insurance company has a clearer picture of your overall medical needs and the potential long-term costs associated with your claim. They can then more accurately assess your past and future medical expenses, lost wages due to your injury, and any potential disability benefits you may be entitled to. With this information, they can present a settlement offer that they believe reflects the full value of your claim.
However, it’s important to remember that reaching MMI doesn’t automatically trigger a settlement offer. The insurance company may still dispute the extent of your injuries, the necessity of ongoing treatment, or your ability to return to work. In such cases, mediation or litigation may be necessary to resolve the dispute and reach a settlement agreement.
A Guide to Permanent Total Disability (PTD) Benefits
in NC
Learn about permanent total disability (PTD) benefits after a work injury in NC, including which injuries qualify and how to maximize your benefits.
During mediation or before trial
While insurance companies may not be eager to settle early on, their perspective often changes as the case progresses. As the trial date approaches, the insurer faces increased pressure to resolve the claim to avoid the uncertainties and potential costs of litigation. This is where mediation can play a crucial role.
Mediation is a process in which a neutral third party facilitates negotiations between you and the insurance company. It provides an opportunity to reach a mutually agreeable settlement without the need for a formal hearing.
In North Carolina, mediation is often encouraged or even required before a hearing can be scheduled. If mediation is successful, you and the insurance company will sign a settlement agreement that outlines the terms of your compensation. If mediation fails, your case will proceed to a hearing before the North Carolina Industrial Commission, where a Deputy Commissioner will make a final decision on your claim.
Because most insurance companies don’t want to take the risk of going to trial and potentially facing a larger payout, they may become more open to negotiating a fair settlement during mediation. This is particularly true if your attorney has built a strong case demonstrating the validity of your claim and the extent of your damages.
What percentage does workers’ comp pay in NC?
In North Carolina, workers’ compensation typically pays two-thirds (66.67%) of your average weekly wage as indemnity benefits (wage loss benefits) if you’re unable to work due to a work-related injury.
However, these benefits are not subject to state or federal income taxes, which means your take-home pay might be similar to what you were earning before your injury.
It’s important to note that there are minimum and maximum limits on these benefits. As of 2024, the maximum weekly benefit you can receive is $1,330.00, regardless of your pre-injury earnings. If two-thirds of your average weekly wage falls below the minimum limit (which is $30 in 2024), you’ll receive the minimum amount.
What Workers’ Compensation Benefits Are Available in North Carolina?
Learn about the 4 types of workers’ comp benefits you may be entitled to after a work injury in Charlotte.
How do I know if my workers’ comp settlement offer is fair?
Determining whether a workers’ compensation settlement offer is fair can be complex and requires careful consideration of various factors. Here are some key questions to ask yourself:
- Does it cover all my medical expenses? Workers’ comp provides medical benefits for past, current, and estimated future medical costs related to your injury. Ensure that the settlement covers doctor visits, hospitalizations, surgeries, medications, physical therapy, and any assistive devices or future care you may need.
- Does it compensate me for lost wages? The settlement should cover all the wages you’ve lost due to your inability to work during your recovery. This includes permanent partial disability (PPD) benefits and permanent total disability (PTD) benefits, if applicable.
- Does it account for vocational rehabilitation? If your injury prevents you from returning to your previous job but you’re still capable of working in some capacity, the settlement should include provisions for vocational rehabilitation to help you re-enter the workforce.
- Have I considered future complications? It’s crucial to think about the possibility of future complications or the need for additional treatment related to your injury, so be sure you have a thorough understanding of your medical condition when considering a settlement offer.
- Have I factored in legal fees and costs? If you have an attorney, their fees and other legal costs should be considered when evaluating the fairness of the settlement offer.
- Is it a lump sum or a structured settlement? Consider the pros and cons of each option, and choose the one that best suits your financial needs and goals.
- Have I consulted with an attorney? An experienced workers’ compensation attorney can help you evaluate the settlement offer, negotiate with the insurance company, and ensure you receive fair compensation for your injuries.
If your injury gets worse after reaching a settlement, reopening a North Carolina workers’ comp claim isn’t always possible, so it’s crucial to discuss the terms of your settlement with a qualified workers’ compensation attorney before signing anything.
Need help negotiating a workers’ comp settlement in Charlotte?
If you are an injured worker in North Carolina and need assistance negotiating a workers’ compensation settlement or determining if a settlement offer is fair, consider reaching out to Wilder Pantazis Law Group.
With over 85 years of combined experience, our knowledgeable Charlotte work injury attorneys are dedicated to helping you navigate the complexities of workers’ compensation claims and secure the compensation you deserve.